Same-Day Substitution

Written By
Paul Tracy
Updated November 4, 2020

What is Same-Day Substitution?

Same-day substitution is the act of withdrawing money from and adding money to a margin account on the same day.

How Does Same-Day Substitution Work?

Let's assume you want to buy 500 shares of Company XYZ for $5 per share and 500 shares of Company ABC for $5 per share but don't have the $5,000 necessary to do so -- you only have $2,500. If you buy the shares on margin, you essentially borrow the other half of the money from the brokerage firm and collateralize the loan with the shares. This original loan amount as a percentage of the investment amount is the initial margin.

If the value of the shares drops past a certain point, say 25% of the original $5 value (or $1.25 per share; this point is called the maintenance margin), the brokerage firm may make a margin call, meaning that within a few days you must deposit more cash or sell some of the shares to offset all or part of the difference between the actual stock price and the maintenance margin.

However, if the value of Company XYZ falls but the value of Company ABC increases by the same amount, the same-say substitution effect means that the account balance stays the same and you avoid getting a margin call.

Why Does Same-Day Substitution Matter?

Margin accounts allow investors to make investments with their brokers' money. A margin call is a brokerage firm's demand that a margin-account client make up the difference between a security's price and a minimum maintenance margin.

Margin accounts can magnify gains, but they can also magnify losses. Getting a margin call means that not only do you have to pay back the original $2,500 of principal eventually, but you have to pay the margin call. In some cases, a brokerage firm can sell an investor's securities without notification or even sue if the investor does not fulfill a margin call. However, if the stock rises from $5 to, say, $15, you've just made $10,000 without investing all of your own money. For these reasons, margin accounts are generally for more sophisticated investors who understand and can handle the risks involved.

Activate your free account to unlock our most valuable savings and money-making tips
  • 100% FREE
  • Exclusive money-making tips before we post them to the live site
  • Weekly insights and analysis from our financial experts
  • Free Report - 25 Ways to Save Hundreds on Your Monthly Expenses
  • Free Report - Eliminate Credit Card Debt with these 10 Simple Tricks
Ask an Expert
All of our content is verified for accuracy by Paul Tracy and our team of certified financial experts. We pride ourselves on quality, research, and transparency, and we value your feedback. Below you'll find answers to some of the most common reader questions about Same-Day Substitution.
Be the first to ask a question

If you have a question about Same-Day Substitution, then please ask Paul.

Ask a question

Paul has been a respected figure in the financial markets for more than two decades. Prior to starting InvestingAnswers, Paul founded and managed one of the most influential investment research firms in America, with more than 3 million monthly readers.

If you have a question about Same-Day Substitution, then please ask Paul.

Ask a question Read more from Paul
Paul Tracy - profile
Ask an Expert about Same-Day Substitution

By submitting this form you agree with our Privacy Policy

Don't Know a Financial Term?
Search our library of 4,000+ terms